Coffee Mate – Dirty Soda (Dirty Dr Pepper) Review
Ever seen someone pour Coffee Mate into Dr Pepper and wondered if they’ve lost their mind? Same. The idea of mixing a creamy coffee creamer with a fizzy, spiced soda sounds like a recipe for disaster. But people swear by it and call it smooth.
So, I put this bizarre drink to the test. The first few sips were surprisingly good—like a soda float, but smoother. Then, things took a turn. Was it delicious? Kind of. In short, here’s my Coffee mate – Dirty Soda (dirty Dr Pepper) Review:
| Category | Rating (Out of 10) | Comments |
| Appearance | 6 | Creamy brown, looks like fizzy iced coffee. A bit odd. |
| Smell | 5 | Smells like Dr Pepper mixed with melted vanilla ice cream. Confusing but not bad. |
| Taste | 7 | Starts smooth and creamy, but becomes overwhelming after a while. |
| Sweetness | 3 | Extremely sweet, like liquid sugar. Too much for regular drinking. |
| Texture | 5 | Light and fizzy at first, but turns thick and syrupy as it sits. |
| Carbonation | 4 | Loses fizz quickly, making it feel heavier. Not as refreshing. |
| Overall | 5 | Fun to try once, but too sweet and heavy for regular enjoyment. |
Want to know if Coffee Mate – Dirty Soda (Dirty Dr Pepper) is worth trying? I’m sharing my full, unfiltered review, plus step-by-step instructions to make it at home. Let’s get started.
Coffee mate – Dirty Soda (dirty Dr Pepper) Review
I’ll never forget the moment I bought Coffee Mate and Dr Pepper together. The cashier at the gas station paused mid-scan and stared at me. I could feel the judgment. “You drink these… together?” she asked, her face full of concern.
I laughed like it was a joke, but deep down, I wasn’t so sure myself.
I had seen people online swearing that adding Coffee Mate to Dr Pepper changed their lives. Some called it the best thing ever. Others called it a mistake they couldn’t undo. I needed to know which side I was on.
I got home, poured a full glass of ice, cracked open the Dr Pepper, and gave myself a pep talk. This was happening. I grabbed my Coffee Mate French Vanilla, took a deep breath, and poured in a good amount. I had no idea what I was about to experience, but I was ready.
First Impressions
The first thing I noticed when I saw Coffee Mate – Dirty Soda (dirty Dr Pepper) was that this drink did not want to mix. The Coffee Mate floated on top like it was afraid to touch the soda. It just sat there, mocking me. I stirred it aggressively, and eventually, the drink turned into a creamy brown color. It looked like iced coffee with bubbles, which immediately felt wrong.
I leaned in to smell it, and my brain short-circuited. Dr Pepper already has a strong scent—cherry, vanilla, spice. But now, it smelled like someone had melted a vanilla milkshake into it. It was confusing. Was this a soda? A dessert? A terrible idea? I had no answers, but I was already in too deep.
I took a sip, praying for the best.
Flavor Profile of Coffee mate – Dirty Soda (dirty Dr Pepper)
The first thing that hit me was how ridiculously smooth it was. Dr Pepper usually has that sharp, spicy kick, but the Coffee Mate took all the edges off. It was soft, creamy, and tasted like someone had blended cream soda, cherry cola, and vanilla frosting into one drink.
For the first few sips, I actually liked it. It was weirdly addictive. The flavors blended surprisingly well, and it reminded me of a soda float after the ice cream has melted. I started thinking, “Wait, is this actually good?”
Then I kept drinking.
By the halfway point, I realized I had made a mistake. This drink was so sweet it should come with a warning label. I felt like I had drunk an entire birthday cake. It didn’t just taste sugary—it felt like the sugar was taking over my body. The more I drank, the heavier it got. It wasn’t just too sweet. It was aggressively sweet.
I needed a palate cleanser. Maybe something simple, like… water. Or a salad.
Mouthfeel & Texture
At first, the texture of Coffee mate – Dirty Soda (dirty Dr Pepper) was interesting. It was fizzy, but the Coffee Mate made it feel creamy and thick. It was like drinking a milkshake with carbonation. The first few sips were fun, but as I kept going, the carbonation started to disappear.
By the time I got to the bottom of the glass, the Coffee Mate had settled into a syrupy layer. The last few sips weren’t creamy and fizzy. They were straight-up thick. It felt like I was drinking melted ice cream with a splash of soda. I stirred it again, but at that point, I was just trying to finish it so I could move on with my life.
Final Thoughts
Would I again drink Coffee mate – Dirty Soda (dirty Dr Pepper)? No. Do I regret trying this drink? Also no.
I get why some people like it. It’s sweet, creamy, and comforting. If you love soda floats, dessert-like drinks, or the idea of drinking cake batter, this is probably your thing. But for me, it was too much.
I like my soda crisp, refreshing, and balanced. This drink was thick, overpowering, and borderline chaotic. It started off fun, but by the end, I felt like I had consumed a mistake in liquid form.
Would I recommend trying it? Yes—just once. It’s one of those things you have to taste for yourself.
If you think Dirty Dr Pepper is a wild drink combo, wait until you hear about Dr Pepper with Pickles—here’s my full review and how to make it!
How to Make Coffee mate – Dirty Soda (dirty Dr Pepper) at Home
The first time I tried this, I was 100% sure it was going to be disgusting. I grabbed a Dr Pepper, poured it over ice, and added Coffee Mate French Vanilla. It wasn’t as bad as I thought. Weird? Yes. Drinkable? Shockingly, also yes.
Now, if you’re curious, here’s how you can make Coffee mate – Dirty Soda (dirty Dr Pepper) at home.
Step 1: Gather Your Ingredients
Coffee mate – Dirty Soda (dirty Dr Pepper) drink is stupidly simple to make. No blending, no measuring, no weird ingredients. Here’s what you need:
- A can of Dr Pepper (12 oz) – Regular is best. Diet works, but the flavor is thinner.
- Coffee Mate creamer – French Vanilla is the classic choice. Caramel, Sweet Cream, or Hazelnut also work.
- Ice cubes – Helps balance the texture and keeps it cold.
- A straw (optional) – You’ll want one to stir and sip properly.
That’s it. Four things.
Step 2: Fill a Glass with Ice
I highly recommend using ice. Without it, the drink feels way too heavy. The ice makes it lighter, smoother, and more refreshing.
Fill your glass all the way to the top. Big ice cubes are great because they melt slower, but crushed ice blends better with the soda and creamer. Either works. Just don’t skip the ice, or you’ll end up with a warm, weirdly thick soda.
Step 3: Pour in the Dr Pepper
Now, pour the Dr Pepper slowly over the ice. If you pour too fast, it’ll foam up like crazy and take forever to settle. Trust me, I made that mistake.
Leave about an inch of space at the top. You need room for the Coffee Mate, or you’ll end up with soda overflowing onto your counter. Not fun.
At this point, your drink still looks totally normal. That’s about to change.
Step 4: Add the Coffee Mate
Step four is where things get weird.
Grab your Coffee Mate and pour in 1-2 tablespoons. If you love creamy drinks, add more. If you’re nervous, start small. You can always add more later.
The creamer will sit on top at first, like it’s scared to mix. It looks deeply suspicious. Just trust the process. After a few seconds, it will start swirling into the soda. That’s when things get interesting.
If you use French Vanilla Coffee Mate, it’ll taste like a cream soda float. Caramel Coffee Mate makes it taste like a melted Dr Pepper milkshake. Sweet Cream Coffee Mate keeps it neutral but extra rich.
Now, you just need to mix it.
Step 5: Stir It Like Your Life Depends on It
Right now, your drink looks half-mixed and kind of strange. Grab a spoon or a straw and stir like crazy. The goal is to get the creamer to fully blend into the soda.
If you don’t stir well, the first sip will be 90% soda and 10% thick, unexpected creamer. That is not what you want. Keep mixing until it turns a smooth caramel brown.
Now, it’s time to taste the madness.
Step 6: Take a Sip and See What Happens
I took my first sip and immediately had conflicting thoughts.
The texture was softer than I expected. Dr Pepper usually has that sharp, spicy kick, but the Coffee Mate completely smooths it out. It was sweet, creamy, and almost too easy to drink.
At first, I kind of liked it. It was weird but good. Then I kept drinking.
Halfway through, I realized I had made a mistake. This drink is insanely sweet. Dr Pepper is already full of sugar, and Coffee Mate doubles down on it. After a few sips, I felt like I was drinking a melted cupcake. It wasn’t just sweet—it was too much.
By the time I finished, I needed a glass of water. Maybe even a salad.
Step 7: Decide If This Is for You
Here’s the deal: You’ll know right away if you love or hate this.
- If you love soda floats, milkshakes, or sweet creamy drinks, you’ll probably enjoy it.
- If you like your soda crisp, fizzy, and refreshing, you might regret every sip.
Some people get obsessed with this. Others take two sips and throw it out. You won’t know until you try it.
Dirty sodas are all about creative flavor combinations, and if that excites you, you’ll definitely enjoy my review of Dole Strawberry Lemonade.
Conclusion
If you love sweet, creamy drinks, Coffee Mate Dirty Dr Pepper might be your next obsession. If you prefer crisp, refreshing sodas, this could be too much. Either way, it’s worth trying at least once.
Let’s recap my Coffee mate – Dirty Soda (dirty Dr Pepper) review:
- It starts off smooth and creamy, but the sweetness builds up fast.
- The best flavors to use are vanilla, caramel, or sweet cream.
- You have to stir well, or you’ll get a thick, syrupy sip at the end.
- This drink loses carbonation quickly, so drink it fresh.
- It’s fun to try, but most people either love it or hate it.
Would I drink it again? Maybe—but with less creamer.
